When Your Sad Heart Longs to Know Why

After my dad died last May, I wrestled with “why” for several months.

He was 86 and had lived a long, useful life, so my questions didn’t necessarily have to do with the fact that he had died. They were more about the heartbreaking events that led up to his death—or, if you will, the way he died.

The decline of his health—which was perplexing and sometimes even inexplicable—forced him to spend the last six months of his life in a nursing home. He was at peace at the end, but the long walk home was at times arduous and painful—for him and for us.

Why did it have to be that way? I wondered. Why didn’t God just let him die at home in his sleep like he always thought he would?

As a general rule, I don’t devote a lot of time or energy to this type of questioning. If anything, I’m more inclined to worry about the future—to veer off into what-if land—rather than stew over what has already happened.

In the wake of my dad’s death, though, as I struggled to process the trauma of what had happened, this is where I often found myself. Logically, I knew these were questions that had no answers. I felt like I’d be better off banging my head against a brick wall than to continue to ask why, but my sad heart still wanted to know.

This is, of course, a completely human and understandable response. For a grieving daughter as well as a world full of questions about God’s role in the whole Covid-19 pandemic.

There’s no judgment here if you’re someone who struggles with doubt or wonders why God is allowing current events to play out the way they are. But if you’ve reached the point of head-banging or simply long for a more productive question than “why,” may I suggest an alternative?

Set aside questions like “Why me, God?” and “Why is God allowing this kind of suffering in the world right now?”

Instead, ask yourself, “What about God enables me to trust Him through or in spite of the suffering?”

I’ve written previously about my practice of underlining God’s names and attributes as I read the scriptures. About a month ago, I started going through the Book of Psalms in a new, unmarked Bible.

Every day I find more comforting truth about God and additional reasons to trust Him.

The Psalms don’t tell us why, but they do reassure us that God numbers our days and keeps track of our tears (Psalm 39:4, 56:8). That He understands how we are formed and remembers that we are dust (Psalm 103:14).

They remind us that our good Shepherd spoke the world into existence, that He is King of the whole earth, that He doesn’t withhold his compassion from us, that He is near the brokenhearted, that His way is perfect and His Word is pure. (Psalm 33:9; 47:7; 40:11; 34:18; 18:30)

The Book of Isaiah also provides solid answers when we ask “What is it about God?” rather than why. In Isaiah 12:2, for example, the prophet proclaims “Surely God is my salvation; I will trust and not be afraid. The Lord, the Lord himself, is my strength and my defense; he has become my salvation.” (NIV)

And in Isaiah 41:10, God Himself promises, “ ‘Do not fear, for I am with you; do not anxiously look about you, for I am your God. I will strengthen you, surely I will help you, surely I will uphold you with my righteous right hand.’ ” (NASB)

As for me, the truth of Psalm 139:16—“that all the days ordained for me were written in [God’s] book before one of them came to be”—eventually helped me to release most of the whys about my dad’s death.

It helps me still, as I erase significant life events from our family’s calendar and repeatedly release my expectations of what the future might hold to the only One who knows that future.

I realize, though, that the specific elements of God’s character that are especially comforting to me right now might not be the same ones that encourage you. We’re all different, after all—and specifically designed that way by our sovereign Creator.

So what is it about God that enables you, personally, to trust Him during this uncertain time?

Write it down, all at once or as you read through the Bible each day. And please, if you don’t mind, share it with us too. We’re all in this together, and I can’t help but think that what encourages you will encourage someone else too.

♥ Lois

P.S. I’m linking up this week with Purposeful Faith, #TellHisStory, InstaEncouragements, Recharge Wednesday, #HeartEncouragement, Let’s Have Coffee and Grace & Truth.